Some people cruise into new roles, all slick and understated. I, on the other hand, tend to stumble in, trip over my own tongue, and bruise my ego in the process. Here’s a story from my big, fat Noob File.
I had seen an notice on a blog advising of a literary agent looking for writers who had had experiences as exchange students. Ooh! That’s me, I thought to myself. I read on. This New York agent had a series in mind, each book featuring an American exchange student in a different country. I’d always imagined writing about my exchange experience in Italy. Here was my chance.
I contacted the agent in NYC. That whole experience was surreal, mainly because I had NO idea what I was doing. I just plunged in taking wild guesses and crossing my fingers. My first contact was based on my assumption of what she might be looking for in a YA writer. Based on that (mis)conception, I crafted a letter about my “wild” (it wasn’t) exchange experience and all of the “boy-crazy shenanigans” I did not actually get up to. It was a fun introductory letter, but it missed the target. Woefully. The reply made it clear that the agent was not into that kind of story, nor was Italy “exotic” enough for her. She asked questions though, which was promising, and she sent me extracts about story shape from two writing manuals.
I remember pondering the significance of her email. Did it mean, “Let’s continue this discussion,” or did it mean, “Go learn something and then maybe we’ll talk?” I opted for both interpretations.
I devoured the texts she’d sent and even bought one of them (Story by Robert McKee). In my next email, I asked if my experiences in China would be exotic enough. Turns out, Asia was more like it.Yes, she would be interested in considering what I had to offer. A bit of silly dancing around my living room ensued before I got down to the serious business of hatching an idea and simultaneously proving I was a hard worker and a good risk.
I toiled to synthesize my story idea, creating in-depth character profiles and outlining my plot. I went to great lengths to format my submission in what I hoped would be a unique and eye-catching way. (Yes, I’m talking full-colour charts and illustrated tables). Naively, I took her comment about the “originality” of my “visual story arc” as praise, noob that I was. In the end she chose another writer, which was disappointing to say the least.
By that point, I was rather besotted with my book idea, so I decided to go ahead and write it without her endorsement. I’d shared the story, which I titled A Thousand Miles to Meet, with two of my closest friends, and both of them teared up and gushed support. Wow! I thought, If a synopsis can make two grown women cry, it must be a keeper.
I wrote like a mad woman. At the end of the holidays, I had about 20,000 words. Not a bad effort considering I was writing about a city I’d never been to. On the day I returned to work, guess who contacted me out of the blue? The agent. It turns out the writer she chose for the project had backed out. I nearly backflipped in my desk chair, I was so excited. And how good was it that I had something to show her! I couldn’t help praying that this would be my “big break.”
In that embarrassingly nooby way, I got a little ahead of myself. I’ll blame a lack of experience, but it was more about my unbridled enthusiasm and my deep-seated need for affirmation. Yuck.
It turns out the agent wanted her story more than she wanted mine–all for sound business reasons, no doubt. I made several attempts to recast my idea into the thing she was seeking. I mean I gave it a really good go, chopping and changing, even abandoning key themes and cherished turning points. After three rewrites and about 50,000 unaccepted words written over a three-week period, I decided to cut my losses. Maybe I wasn’t ready to write someone else’s story. Hopefully one day I will be.
Despite (or possibly because of) the disappointment, I learned so much in this exchange. The agent was professional and generous with her guidance. I’m glad I went for the whole bewildering roller coaster ride even though it didn’t end with a book contract. I learnt the value of professionalism. To be taken seriously as a writer, it is best to stick with normal protocols. Anything more (like lurid documents) smacks of inexperience. Even enthusiasm can seem sophomoric. Be a pro. Lesson learned.
A post-script to finish this little tale: what became of the story A Thousand Miles to Meet? After being sliced, diced, and blended, it ended up with with four not-quite-good-enough beginnings. I lost both my direction and my passion for the project in the process. As a result, the manuscript sat smoldering in a folder for six months. On a whim, I sent off the story with my original beginning as an entry in the YA fiction category of the 2011 CYA Conference Competition. It took 5th place! The score it received was only 8 points below what my other entry, Saving Aggie Blue, received. And Aggie won second place! Makes me wonder if I should pick it up again…